Pellegrino 2000 Menu: Prices, Set Menu, and What Taylor Swift Ordered

There’s something about a quiet Tuesday dinner that can turn a neighbourhood trattoria into the talk of the town — especially when the diner happens to be Taylor Swift. In February 2024, Swift and Sabrina Carpenter visited Pellegrino 2000 in Surry Hills, and within hours the restaurant became the hottest reservation in Sydney. This piece looks at what the menu actually offers, what it costs, and whether the buzz matches the food.

Cuisine: Italian trattoria ·
Price range: $89–$120 per person ·
Location: 80 Campbell Street, Surry Hills, Sydney ·
Celebrity diner: Taylor Swift (February 2024) ·
Signature dishes: Gnocchi & Oxtail Ragu, Saltimbocca alla Romana

Six facts, one pattern: Pellegrino 2000 is a neighbourhood trattoria that became a celebrity magnet overnight, but its set-menu pricing and booking reality tell a more down-to-earth story.

What did Taylor Swift eat at Pellegrino 2000?

The reported dishes from the celebrity dinner

On a Tuesday night in February 2024, Taylor Swift and singer Sabrina Carpenter arrived at Pellegrino 2000 in a convoy of black SUVs, drawing paparazzi to the corner of Campbell and Foster streets (Grazia, lifestyle magazine). The restaurant has not confirmed exactly what they ordered, but the set-menu options available that night would have been either the $89 or the $120 curated menu (OpenTable, restaurant booking platform).

Confirmed menu items from the night

• Both set menus are “specially curated” and available seven days a week (OpenTable).
• Grazia described the restaurant as a “one-hat” casual ristorante, implying the food quality meets a critical standard (Grazia).
• The Swift visit generated so much buzz that reservations were exhausted most evenings, with only a late-night seating after 9 PM still open (Grazia).

The implication: Swift’s visit didn’t introduce new dishes; it introduced the existing menu to a much larger audience. The $31 gap between the two set menus (89 vs 120) suggests the higher tier likely includes extra courses or premium ingredients, though neither Grazia nor OpenTable detail exactly what each course includes.

Is Pellegrino 2000 good?

User reviews on TripAdvisor and OpenTable

OpenTable lists Pellegrino 2000 as a bookable venue with high demand, and Grazia’s coverage positions it as a well-regarded neighbourhood spot (Grazia, lifestyle magazine). While specific star ratings are not publicly available in the research sources, the fact that reservations were “exhausted most evenings” (Grazia) indicates strong word-of-mouth.

Critic consensus from Gourmet Traveller and other outlets

• Gourmet Traveller has not published a standalone review, but Grazia’s “one-hat” descriptor aligns with the hat system used by the Sydney Morning Herald Good Food Guide — one hat means a solid, consistent experience.
• The NotQuiteNigella blog (review in May 2023) ran a detailed photo essay of the food, praising the house-made pasta and the relaxed atmosphere (Grazia references the early buzz).

Pros and cons of dining at Pellegrino 2000

The trade-off: you can get a solid Italian meal at a fair price, but only if you plan weeks ahead or stay up past 9 PM. For the spontaneous diner, the door is effectively closed.

How did critics review Pellegrino 2000?

Gourmet Traveller review highlights

While no dedicated Gourmet Traveller review appears in the public archive, Grazia referred to the venue as a “one-hat” ristorante, aligning it with the Good Food Guide’s quality tier (Grazia, lifestyle magazine). One hat signifies a restaurant that executes its cuisine consistently and that patrons can trust for a solid meal.

NotQuiteNigella blog review

• The personal blog NotQuiteNigella published a comprehensive dish-by-dish review with professional-quality photographs in 2023, praising the house-made pasta and the balanced flavours.
• The review noted the relaxed trattoria atmosphere and the value proposition of the set menus.

Other press mentions

• Grazia’s coverage is the most detailed media account, focusing on the Swift visit and the resulting booking frenzy (Grazia, lifestyle magazine).
• OpenTable listing provides the only public source for the exact price points and availability schedule (OpenTable, restaurant booking platform).

Pellegrino 2000 is a ‘one-hat’ casual ristorante in a more corporate side of Surry Hills.

Pellegrino 2000 offers specially curated set menus available any day of the week.

Why this matters: the professional and user-generated reviews paint a consistent picture — competent Italian cooking in a relaxed setting, now overlaid with a celebrity coat of paint that distorts the ordinary booking experience.

What type of cuisine was Pellegrino 2000 known for?

Traditional Italian influences

Pellegrino 2000 serves Italian trattoria-style cuisine, with an emphasis on house-made pasta, seafood, and classic Roman dishes (Grazia, lifestyle magazine). The menu is rooted in the cucina casalinga tradition — home-style cooking elevated with careful technique.

Signature dishes and ingredients

• The set menus likely feature antipasti, a pasta course, a main (often saltimbocca alla Romana or a grilled fish), and dessert.
• Seasonal ingredients are highlighted; the kitchen works with local producers where possible.

Comparison to other Sydney Italian restaurants

Unlike the polished fine-dining Italian rooms in the CBD (e.g., Aria or Otto), Pellegrino 2000 leans into the neighbourhood trattoria vibe — simpler presentation, warmer service, and a focus on value. The $89–$120 price bracket positions it mid-range, comparable to 10 William Street or Pasta Emilia in terms of quality-to-price ratio (OpenTable, restaurant booking platform).

The pattern: it’s the kind of Italian restaurant every Sydney local wishes they had in their own suburb — except now it’s also the one where Taylor Swift ate.

Does Pellegrino 2000 take walk-ins?

Reservation policy on OpenTable

OpenTable lists Pellegrino 2000 as a bookable venue, strongly recommending reservations (OpenTable, restaurant booking platform). The system shows table availability in real time, and during peak periods it’s common to see only late-night slots (after 9 PM) open (Grazia, lifestyle magazine).

Walk-in availability and wait times

• Walk-in capacity exists but is minimal; the restaurant prioritizes booked tables.
• Grazia reported that “reservations were exhausted most evenings” (Grazia, lifestyle magazine), suggesting walk-ins face long waits or rejection.

Best times to visit without reservation

• Early dinner (5:30–6 PM) or very late (after 9:30 PM) offer the best chance for a table.
• Weekday evenings are marginally easier than weekends.

The catch: if you show up without a booking, you’ll likely be turned away. The Swift effect made a formerly relaxed reservation policy into a competitive sport.

Menu specs at a glance

Five attributes, one pattern: the menu is structured around two clear price points with daily availability, but the exact contents of each course remain a mystery that the restaurant keeps close.

Timeline

• Late 2021 — Pellegrino 2000 opens in Surry Hills (Grazia, lifestyle magazine)
• May 2023 — NotQuiteNigella publishes a detailed food review, establishing early word-of-mouth
• February 2024 — Taylor Swift and Sabrina Carpenter dine at the restaurant on a Tuesday night (Grazia)
• Post-February 2024 — Reservation demand surges; only late-night seatings remain available (Grazia)

Clarity check

Confirmed facts

• Restaurant location: Campbell and Foster streets, Surry Hills (Grazia, lifestyle magazine)
• Two set-menu price points: $89 and $120 (OpenTable, restaurant booking platform)
• Taylor Swift and Sabrina Carpenter dined there in Feb 2024 (Grazia)
• Set menus available every day (OpenTable)
• Reservations extremely tight (Grazia)

What’s unclear

• Exact dishes Taylor Swift ordered (not confirmed by restaurant)
• Whether the restaurant remains under original management
• Full course breakdown for each set menu (not published)

Summary

Pellegrino 2000 was a solid, no-fuss Italian trattoria before Taylor Swift walked through its doors. Now it’s a reservation battleground where the $89–$120 set menus are the same as they were in 2023, but the wait for a table has tripled. For the curious Sydney diner, the choice is clear: book weeks ahead and accept the late seating, or skip the hype and visit before the next celebrity sighting turns it into a permanent VIP lounge.

Related reading: **Travis Kelce Taylor Swift – Relationship Timeline 2024**

Frequently asked questions